hist.g8.f.lesson_19
Dawes Act 1887 + Carlisle Indian Industrial School 1879 + Pratt 'Kill the Indian, Save the Man' + 408 Federal Boarding Schools as Cultural Genocide [TRAUMA-INFORMED]
- Students analyze Dawes General Allotment Act Feb 8 1887 as instrument of Indigenous land dispossession (138M acres 1887 -> 48M by 1934 = 65% loss) per Treuer 2019 + Dunbar-Ortiz 2014.
- Students close-read Pratt 'Kill the Indian, save the man' July 4 1892 speech + Zitkala-Ša 'School Days of an Indian Girl' Feb 1900 + Luther Standing Bear 1933 + Newland 2022 US DOI Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative — naming 408 federal boarding schools as cultural genocide.
Lesson plan
Warm-up
5 minMG-15 PROTOCOL active: caregiver letter sent in advance. Bridge: today policies of cultural genocide — Dawes Act land dispossession + 408 federal boarding schools — named honestly per Treuer 2019 + Newland 2022.
- Activate MG-15
- Display MG-19 Boarding School diagram
- Display Pratt + Zitkala-Ša + Standing Bear + Black Elk portraits
Direct instruction
15 minDAWES GENERAL ALLOTMENT ACT Feb 8 1887 — broke up communal tribal land into individual 160-acre allotments (head of family) or 80-acre (single adult); excess land sold to white settlers. Per Treuer 2019 + Dunbar-Ortiz 2014 + Blackhawk 2023: Dawes Act was DELIBERATE INSTRUMENT of land dispossession that reduced Indigenous land base from 138M acres 1887 -> 48M by 1934 = 65% loss in 47 years. Intent was to destroy collective tribal land tenure + assimilate Indigenous people into white agricultural economy. Reform-era white advocates (Indian Rights Association + similar) genuinely believed allotment + Christianity + English-language education would 'civilize' Indigenous peoples — Indigenous response then + now: these were instruments of dispossession + cultural destruction. Burke Act 1906 + Curtis Act 1898 (extended allotment to Five Civilized Tribes) accelerated land loss. Indian Reorganization Act 1934 ended allotment + began modest reversal — but 65% land loss was already complete. CARLISLE INDIAN INDUSTRIAL SCHOOL — founded 1879 Carlisle PA (former US Cavalry barracks) by Capt. Richard Henry Pratt (US Cavalry Civil War + Indian Wars veteran). First federal off-reservation boarding school for Indigenous children. First class arrived Oct 6 1879: 82 children from Lakota (Spotted Tail's Rosebud + Red Cloud's Pine Ridge) + Cheyenne + Kiowa nations. Children had hair cut + traditional clothing burned + given Anglo names + forbidden from speaking native languages (punishments included beatings + mouth-washing with soap) + assigned 'outing' summer work for white families (effectively domestic + farm labor). Per Adams 1995 Education for Extinction + Child 1998 Boarding School Seasons (Red Lake Ojibwe author) the explicit policy was cultural genocide. PRATT 1892 SPEECH — Capt. Pratt delivered speech to Nineteenth Annual Conference of Charities and Correction Denver CO July 4 1892 — published in Americanizing the American Indian (Francis Paul Prucha ed. 1973 Harvard UP). Full quote: 'A great general has said that the only good Indian is a dead one, and that high sanction of his destruction has been an enormous factor in promoting Indian massacres. In a sense, I agree with the sentiment, but only in this: that all the Indian there is in the race should be dead. Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.' Pratt's verbatim words are taught as PERPETRATOR PRIMARY SOURCE — explicitly identified as cultural-genocide policy statement per Treuer 2019 + Adams 1995 + Newland 2022. NEWLAND 2022 — US Department of the Interior Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report Volume 1 (May 2022 + Volume 2 July 2024) — first US federal investigation. Led by Bryan Newland (Bay Mills Indian Community Ojibwe; US Assistant Secretary for Indian Affairs 2021-2024) + commissioned by Deb Haaland (Laguna Pueblo; US Secretary of Interior 2021-2025; first Indigenous US Cabinet Secretary). Documents 408 federal boarding schools 1819-1969 across 37 states + 50+ marked + unmarked burial sites + thousands of Indigenous child deaths. Names schools + locations + denominational affiliations + estimated student populations + documented abuse patterns. Per NABS — National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition (founded 2012 by Indigenous activists incl. Christine Diindiisi McCleave Ojibwe) — boarding-school policy is intergenerational trauma that continues to affect Indigenous families today. INDIGENOUS-SURVIVOR VOICES — ZITKALA-ŠA (Gertrude Simmons Bonnin Yankton Dakota 1876-1938; attended White's Manual Labor Institute Indiana 1884+ at age 8): 'The School Days of an Indian Girl' Atlantic Monthly Feb 1900 — describes arrival at boarding school + hair cutting trauma (her hair held the spirit of her family — cutting it was spiritual violation). LUTHER STANDING BEAR (Óta Kté Oglala Lakota 1868-1939): was in very first Carlisle class Oct 1879 at age 11; My People the Sioux 1928 + Land of the Spotted Eagle 1933 — own-voice account of arrival + hair cutting + naming + language suppression. BLACK ELK 1932 (DeMallie 1984 caveats re Neihardt amanuensis): his children + grandchildren attended boarding schools; intergenerational testimony.
-
Apply MG-9 Living-Descendant: Indigenous survivor voices Zitkala-Ša + Standing Bear + Black Elk + Treuer center the response.model REFUTED. Per Adams 1995 Education for Extinction + Treuer 2019 + Newland 2022: Pratt's statement was the EXPLICIT OPERATIONAL POLICY of Carlisle + 408 federal boarding schools 1819-1969. Indigenous children were forcibly removed from families + had hair cut + traditional clothing burned + forbidden to speak native languages + punished physically + thousands died. Current historiography (Treuer 2019 + Adams 1995 + Child 1998 + NABS + Newland 2022) NAMES this as CULTURAL GENOCIDE — per Article II of UN Genocide Convention 1948 which includes 'forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.' Apply MG-14a-equivalent for Indigenous cultural genocide: we say plainly this was cultural genocide; we refuse 'well-intentioned' framing.prompt Apply Q9 to claim Pratt's 'Kill the Indian, save the man' was 'unfortunate phrasing' or 'well-intentioned.'
-
model First US federal investigation acknowledging boarding-school harm. Led by Indigenous officials (Bryan Newland Bay Mills Ojibwe + Deb Haaland Laguna Pueblo). Documents 408 federal schools 1819-1969 in 37 states + 50+ marked + unmarked burial sites + thousands of Indigenous child deaths. Volume 2 July 2024 included historical apology + recommendations for federal-tribal healing partnerships. Per NABS + Indigenous communities Newland 2022 + Pope Francis's 2022 apology for Catholic Church role in Canadian residential schools mark turning point in mainstream acknowledgment of cultural-genocide history. Connect to Canadian Truth and Reconciliation Commission 2008-2015 (215 children's unmarked graves discovered at Kamloops Residential School BC May 2021 was catalyst).prompt Why is Newland 2022 historically important?
- Per Treuer 2019 + Newland 2022 — how should we name boarding-school policy?
- How many acres did Indigenous nations lose 1887-1934 per Dawes Act?
- Apply Q9 to 'Pratt's statement was unfortunate phrasing' — refute.
M-8-F-CUL-19-A
Diagram
18x24 wall display (TRAUMA-INFORMED protocol active) showing Carlisle Indian Industrial School 1879 founding + Pratt 'Kill the Indian, save the man' July 4 1892 quoted in full + explicitly named as cultural-genocide statement per Treuer 2019 + Adams 1995 + NABS + Newland 2022; 408 federal boarding schools 1819-1969 mapped across 37 states per Newland 2022 + 50+ marked/unmarked burial sites + thousands of Indigenous child deaths; before/after photographs of student arrival (group portraits only of Carlisle 'before' showing students in own clothing + Carlisle 'after' uniform photographs side-by-side per Pratt's own propaganda use — taught critically); Indigenous-survivor voices centered: Zitkala-Ša + Luther Standing Bear + Black Elk + Treuer; National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition NABS founded 2012 highlighted as contemporary continuing work.
MG-19
Diagram
Boarding School / Cultural Genocide Diagram — 18x24 inch wall display (with trauma-informed protocol active) showing Carlisle Indian Industrial School 1879 founding + Pratt's 'Kill the Indian, save the man' July 4 1892 quoted in full and explicitly named as cultural-genocide statement per Treuer 2019 + Adams 1995 + NABS + Newland 2022; 408 federal boarding schools 1819-1969 mapped across 37 states per Newland 2022 + 50+ marked/unmarked burial sites + thousands of Indigenous child deaths; before/after photographs of student arrival (carefully chosen group portraits of Carlisle's 'before' and 'after' uniform photographs side-by-side per Pratt's own propaganda use — taught critically); Indigenous-survivor voices centered: Zitkala-Ša 1900 + Luther Standing Bear 1933 + Black Elk 1932 + Treuer 2019; National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition NABS founded 2012 highlighted as contemporary continuing work.
M-8-F-CUL-19-B
Chart
Chart showing Indigenous-controlled land 1887 (138M acres) -> 1934 (48M acres) = 65% loss in 47 years per Treuer 2019 + Dunbar-Ortiz 2014; pie chart breakdown by tribe + state; caption naming Dawes Act Feb 8 1887 + Burke Act 1906 + Curtis Act 1898 as accelerants + Indian Reorganization Act 1934 as modest reversal.
Guided practice
10 min-
Pairs: read Pratt 1892 speech excerpt + apply MG-7 + Q9; explicitly name as PERPETRATOR primary source.scaffold Annotated edition with sentence frames
-
Pairs: read Zitkala-Ša Atlantic Monthly 1900 OR Standing Bear 1933; identify hair-cutting + language suppression + naming as cultural-genocide instruments.scaffold Annotated student edition
M-8-F-CUL-19-C
Photograph
Composite: Zitkala-Ša (Gertrude Simmons Bonnin Yankton Dakota 1876-1938) c.1898 photograph + Luther Standing Bear (Óta Kté Oglala Lakota 1868-1939; Carlisle first class Oct 1879) c.1890 + Newland 2022 US DOI Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report cover + Deb Haaland (Laguna Pueblo first Indigenous US Cabinet Secretary) photograph; caption with key dates + own-voice publications + 408 documented schools + 50+ burial sites + thousands of child deaths.
Formative assessment
5 min- How many acres did Indigenous nations lose 1887-1934?
- When was Carlisle founded + by whom?
- Quote Pratt 1892 verbatim + apply Q9.
Closure
5 min- COMPASSION CIRCLE close (MG-15)
- Add 1 sticky to MG-6
- Preview L20: Chinese Exclusion + Industrial-Gilded labor + Capstone
Homework
15 min- Read 1-page Zitkala-Ša Feb 1900 OR Standing Bear 1933 hair-cutting passage; write 1 paragraph applying MG-7 + NMAI present-tense.
Exercises in this lesson
Differentiation
- MG-15 sensory-quiet space
- Pratt 1892 + Zitkala-Ša + Standing Bear annotated editions
- Newland 2022 executive summary
- Read Treuer 2019 ch.1-2 OR Adams 1995 ch.4 + paragraph essay applying cultural-genocide framework
- Research NABS National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition + current healing work
- Bilingual editions
- Pre-teach vocabulary (cultural genocide + Dawes allotment + cultural survival)
- MG-15 alternative-assignment
- Reduced text
Teacher notes
Lesson 19 covers most difficult content of unit. MG-15 PROTOCOL active. Pratt 1892 must be quoted verbatim AND named as PERPETRATOR primary source — students see what cultural-genocide policy looks like in originator's words. Indigenous-survivor voices (Zitkala-Ša + Standing Bear + Black Elk + Treuer) center the response. Newland 2022 is contemporary federal acknowledgment + opens door to capstone civic-action letters to NABS + Wounded Knee Memorial + Carlisle Indian School Cemetery.