Grade 4 Spring — Research Report Writing, Source Evaluation, Figurative Language Deepening, and Formal/Informal Register
Lesson 6 55 min eng.g4.s.lesson_06.ties_paragraph_meet

Meet TIES — Topic-Sentence, Information, Evidence-with-Citation, So-What

Objectives
  • Students name and use the 4 TIES bands (topic-sentence / information / evidence-with-citation / so-what).
  • Students draft body paragraph 1 (CATEGORY 1) of their research report using the TIES routine.
Vocabulary
topic-sentenceinformationevidence-with-citationso-whatTIES

Lesson plan

Warm-up

5 min

Teacher displays one body paragraph from Pinkney's Sit-In; children identify the 4 TIES bands.

Teacher moves
  • Project the excerpt
  • Mark topic-sentence in purple, information in blue, evidence-with-citation in orange, so-what in green
  • Name each band

Direct instruction

18 min

Today you meet TIES — the 4-band routine for informational body paragraphs. It's the informational sibling of fall's CREEL. Every body paragraph develops ONE CATEGORY of your research topic. The bands: TOPIC-SENTENCE (purple) — names the category the paragraph develops. INFORMATION (blue) — expands on the category in your own words (uses your paraphrased notes). EVIDENCE-WITH-CITATION (orange) — a specific fact, quote, statistic, or example with signal-phrase attribution to the source. SO-WHAT (green) — explains why this category matters for the research topic; ties it back to the research-thesis. The SO-WHAT is the band G4 researchers most often skip — they assume the evidence speaks for itself. It doesn't. Watch teacher build a TIES paragraph for category 1 (Early Life) of the Sojourner Truth report: 'Sojourner Truth was born into enslavement in upstate New York around 1797. (TOPIC-SENTENCE) Her early life was shaped by enslavement, separation from her family, and the Dutch language she spoke as a child because her enslavers were Dutch. (INFORMATION) According to Patricia McKissack in her biography Sojourner Truth: Ain't I a Woman?, Sojourner was sold four times before she was nine years old. (EVIDENCE-WITH-CITATION) This category of her early life reminds us that her famous voice for freedom was forged in the experience of her own captivity. (SO-WHAT)'

Key examples
  • Notice EVIDENCE-WITH-CITATION uses a signal phrase ('According to Patricia McKissack in her biography...'). SO-WHAT explains why the EARLY LIFE category matters — it ties to the larger thesis about her voice.
    model See narrative — full 4-band paragraph with each band color-coded on the board.
    prompt Teacher builds a TIES paragraph for category 1.
Checks for understanding
  • What does the SO-WHAT band add that evidence-with-citation doesn't?
  • Where in the TIES paragraph does the signal phrase appear?
Media
M-4-S-WR-06-A Chart
Reproduction of MG-3 at 11x17: 4 stacked bands (purple/blue/orange/green) with the Sojourner Truth Category 1 worked exa

Reproduction of MG-3 at 11x17: 4 stacked bands (purple/blue/orange/green) with the Sojourner Truth Category 1 worked example shown beneath, each sentence color-coded to its band, signal phrase highlighted yellow. Print-ready, dyslexic-friendly font.

MG-3 Chart Physical / non-image

TIES body-paragraph anchor chart: a 4-band stacked card — TOPIC-SENTENCE (purple, anchor icon — 'this body paragraph's category for the research topic'), INFORMATION (blue, book icon — 'what the sources tell us about this category'), EVIDENCE-WITH-CITATION (orange, magnifying-glass with quote-marks — 'a specific fact, quote, statistic, or example with signal-phrase attribution to the source'), SO-WHAT (green, lightbulb icon — 'a sentence that explains why this category matters for the research topic'). Worked example below: 'Sojourner Truth was born into enslavement in upstate New York around 1797. (TOPIC-SENTENCE) Her early life was shaped by slavery, separation from her family, and the Dutch language she spoke as a child. (INFORMATION) According to Patricia McKissack in her biography Sojourner Truth: Ain't I a Woman?, Sojourner was sold four times before she was nine years old. (EVIDENCE-WITH-CITATION) This category of her early life reminds us that her famous voice for freedom was forged in the experience of her own captivity. (SO-WHAT)' Print-ready 11x17.

Guided practice

15 min
Tasks
  • Use the color-coded sentence-strip kit (purple/blue/orange/green) to build body paragraph 1 (CATEGORY 1) for YOUR research thesis. Write each band on its colored strip, then transcribe onto paper.
    scaffold MG-3 anchor; sentence-strip kit per pair
  • Share with partner. Partner names each band by color.
    scaffold Sentence frame: 'Your topic-sentence is ___. Your information is ___. Your evidence-with-citation is ___. Your so-what is ___.'
Media
M-4-S-WR-06-B Illustration
Reference image of a Grade-4 TIES paragraph (handwritten) on a research topic 'golden lion tamarin habitat' with each se

Reference image of a Grade-4 TIES paragraph (handwritten) on a research topic 'golden lion tamarin habitat' with each sentence underlined in its band color (purple/blue/orange/green) and signal phrase highlighted yellow with author name circled. Print-ready 8.5x11.

Formative assessment

4 min
Exit ticket
  • Color-annotate your body paragraph 1 with the 4 colors.
  • Move status-tile to DRAFT.
scoring All 4 bands present and color-annotated with signal-phrase visible = mastery; 3 = practicing; 0-2 = reteach.

Closure

1 min
Moves
  • Star your strongest band.
  • Predict: tomorrow we meet signal phrases more deeply.

Homework

12 min
Tasks
  • At home tonight, draft body paragraph 2 (CATEGORY 2) using TIES. Bring tomorrow.

Exercises in this lesson

eng.g4.s.ex_11
Pick CATEGORY 1 from your planner. Use the TIES routine to draft body paragraph 1. Write 5-7 sentences: TOPIC-SENTENCE + INFORMATION +...
ties paragraph draft · diff 3
eng.g4.s.ex_12
Color-mark your TIES paragraph from ex_11. Use 4 colored pencils: purple under topic-sentence, blue under information, orange under...
ties color annotation · diff 2

Differentiation

Scaffolds
  • Pre-written topic-sentence; child writes information + evidence-with-citation + so-what only
  • Sentence-strip kit color-coded
  • Whisper-rehearsal with partner before writing
Extensions
  • Write a SECOND evidence-with-citation after your first, then ONE so-what.
  • Try a different evidence type (paraphrase vs. quote).
English Learners
  • Bilingual MG-3 anchor
  • Bilingual sentence-strip kit
  • Mentor-text excerpt in home language paired with English
Ieps 504s
  • Sentence-strip kit only — no paper transcription required day 6
  • Adult scribe
  • Reduced target: 3 bands only (topic-sentence + evidence-with-citation + so-what)

Teacher notes

TIES is the highest-leverage informational routine of the term — the structural backbone of every body paragraph. Children who internalize the 4 bands draft fluently; children who don't end up with a string of facts. The SO-WHAT band is the move G4 researchers most often skip; ELABORATION-SKIPPING from fall reappears here in informational mode. Watch for evidence-with-citation that uses only an author name without a signal phrase — push for the full phrase ('According to ___,' or '___ writes that ___'). Carry forward — every body paragraph in the term uses TIES.