Grade 2 Spring History - Immigration Stories: Why Families Move, How They Journey, and How They Make Home
Lesson 14 40 min hist.g2.s.lesson_14

What We Keep and What We Adopt

Objectives
  • Students identify cultural retention (what families keep) and cultural adaptation (what families adopt).
  • Students recognize that BOTH happen together.
Vocabulary
retainadoptkeepbecomeheritagetraditionadaptation

Lesson plan

Warm-up

5 min

Revisit identity charts from lesson 1. Which petals are KEEP (from your family's heritage)? Which are ADOPT (from your new place)?

Teacher moves
  • Affirm both
  • Set framing: BOTH IS POSSIBLE

Direct instruction

12 min

Today we name two big ideas: CULTURAL RETENTION (what families KEEP from their place of origin) and CULTURAL ADAPTATION (what families ADOPT in a new place). Allen Say's grandfather kept his Japanese ways AND adopted California ways. Bilal cooks his family's daal AND has friends who learn it. The key idea: BOTH IS POSSIBLE. Families don't have to choose.

Key examples
  • Keeping and becoming happen together.
    model KEEP: the daal recipe, the long patient cooking, the Urdu/Pashto family words. ADOPT: friends from many heritages who learn the recipe.
    prompt What does Bilal's family KEEP? What do they ADOPT?
Checks for understanding
  • What is cultural retention?
  • What is cultural adaptation?
Sourcework
Source type
Saeed Bilal Cooks Daal + Park Bee-bim Bop! + Delacre bilingual + Cisneros Hairs/Pelitos
Routine
KEEP/ADOPT identification across 4 immigrant-author texts
Media
M-2-S-CUL-14-A Chart Physical / non-image

Display chart 24x36 portrait showing MG-9 as detailed in media_global_notes. Three columns (KEEP / BOTH / ADOPT) with visual examples beneath each. Header: 'KEEP AND BECOME - BOTH AT ONCE.' The center column is the most-pointed-to position.

MG-9 Chart
Mounted on classroom wall at child-eye-height. The CENTER column 'BOTH IS POSSIBLE' is INTENTIONAL - this is the unit's

Mounted on classroom wall at child-eye-height. The CENTER column 'BOTH IS POSSIBLE' is INTENTIONAL - this is the unit's central cultural-retention/adaptation move. Used in lesson 14 to introduce the keep-and-become framework. Each child fills in their own KEEP/ADOPT/BOTH card.

M-2-S-CUL-14-C Illustration
Image 11x14 showing 4 book covers stacked: Bilal Cooks Daal (Saeed) / Bee-bim Bop! (Park) / Olinguito A-Z (Delacre) / Ha

Image 11x14 showing 4 book covers stacked: Bilal Cooks Daal (Saeed) / Bee-bim Bop! (Park) / Olinguito A-Z (Delacre) / Hairs Pelitos (Cisneros). Each book has author tradition label. Header: 'FOUR FAMILIES. FOUR HERITAGES.' Style: respectful book reproduction.

Guided practice

12 min
Tasks
  • Fill in a 3-column KEEP/ADOPT/BOTH chart for ONE family (own family or a published family). 2 items per column.
    scaffold Sentence frames; object photo prompts
  • Share one BOTH item with a partner.
Media
M-2-S-CUL-14-B Photograph
Photo set 11x17 with 6 cultural object photographs: (1) handwritten recipe card in Urdu and English; (2) folded Mexican

Photo set 11x17 with 6 cultural object photographs: (1) handwritten recipe card in Urdu and English; (2) folded Mexican rebozo textile; (3) cassette of Korean lullaby music; (4) Lunar New Year card; (5) handwritten name in Mandarin with English transliteration; (6) youth soccer ball. Each photo has caption with family/tradition source. Source line: 'photographs used per family permissions or stock licensing.' Style: respectful, dignified object photography.

Formative assessment

3 min
Exit ticket
  • Name one KEEP and one ADOPT for the family you chose.
scoring Both = mastery

Closure

2 min
Moves
  • Add 'keep', 'adopt' to Word Wall
  • Preview: tomorrow we look at immigrant contributors

Homework

5 min
Tasks
  • Bring (or photograph) one KEEP item from your family to share next lesson (with permission).

Exercises in this lesson

hist.g2.s.cul.cultural_retention_adaptation.ex_01
Sort 6 cultural items (recipe / textile / song / holiday card / name / sports ball) into KEEP / ADOPT / BOTH categories for a sample family.
keep adopt sort · diff 2

Differentiation

Scaffolds
  • Pictorial object cards
  • Sentence frames
Extensions
  • Add a 7th cultural element (music / dance / sport)
English Learners
  • Bilingual KEEP/ADOPT vocabulary in 5 languages
  • Home-language items welcomed
Ieps 504s
  • Adult-supported chart
  • Pictorial responses acceptable

Teacher notes

PROTOCOL: This is one of the unit's joyful lessons. Children may bring food, textiles, recipes - honor every item. Avoid the trap of food-as-only-culture; emphasize language, story, music, name, gesture, and tradition as equal markers of retention. Address Hairs/Pelitos with care - Cisneros's text on family difference is celebratory of variation.