Conduct FORMAL THREE-PASS peer revision — CONTENT, SENTENCE, MECHANICS (CCSS W.6.5)
Exercise Difficulty 3 ~10 min eng.g6.s.ex_19

Pass One Self Audit

MG-16 Chart
3-pass peer-revision protocol anchor: 3-band stacked card. PASS 1 — CONTENT (purple, 14 criteria — extends fall MG-21):

3-pass peer-revision protocol anchor: 3-band stacked card. PASS 1 — CONTENT (purple, 14 criteria — extends fall MG-21): claim arguable / evidence credible / warrant explained / audience considered / counterclaim addressed / structure follows MPO / introduction hooks / conclusion synthesizes. PASS 2 — SENTENCE-LEVEL (blue, 10 criteria — NEW at G6-spring): parallelism applied / anaphora applied / 1 more device applied / active voice default / passive used only deliberately / sentence rhythm varied (short-long mix) / tricolon present somewhere / sentence openings varied / no unnecessary 'there is/are' / no 'be-verb' overuse. PASS 3 — MECHANICS (green, 12 criteria — NEW at G6-spring): pronoun case correct / intensive pronouns correct / pronoun consistency / vague-pronoun antecedents clear / semicolon used correctly (at least once) / colon used correctly (at least once) / commas for nonrestrictive / commas in compound sentences / spelling clean / capitalization clean / quotation punctuation / italics for titles. Bottom rule: 'ONE PASS AT A TIME. Doing all three at once is worse than doing each well.' Print-ready 11x17.

Prompt

Self-audit your literary-analysis essay against MG-16 Pass 1 CONTENT 14 criteria. For each criterion: YES/PARTLY/NO. Note 2-3 revision targets.

M-6-S-WR-EX-19-A Interactive Physical / non-image

MG-16 Pass 1 14-criterion check-off sheet (already specified).

Answer criteria
type rubric
rubric
14 criteria checked + 2-3 revision targets named = 4; 14 checked + 1 target = 3; partial checking = 2; not attempted = 1
Hints
  1. Pass 1 is content-only. Resist commenting on commas.
  2. Top 3 revision targets = 3 specific moves.
Misconceptions to watch
  • Drifts to commas/devices (Pass 2/3 territory).
  • Marks all YES without specific check.