eng.g8.f.lesson_05.synthesis_launch_big6
Synthesis essay launch — Big6 stage 5 + 5 more Tier-2 Set 17 words
- Apply the They-Say/I-Say framework to enter academic conversation (Graff & Birkenstein; CCSS W.8.1.a; W.8.1.b)
- Acquire and use Tier-2 Set 17 academic-synthesis precision vocabulary (CCSS L.8.6; L.8.4.a-d)
- Compose a multi-source synthesis essay integrating ≥3 sources (CCSS W.8.1; W.8.2; W.8.7; W.8.8; W.8.9)
- Students launch their synthesis essay topic and source-portfolio.
- Students apply Big6 stage 5 (synthesis) to their 3 chosen sources.
- Students learn 5 more Tier-2 Set 17 words (articulate, posit, contend, concede, refute).
Lesson plan
Warm-up
5 minPair-share: tell your partner your synthesis topic in 1 sentence. What 3 sources are you using?
- Affirm topic and source choices
- Connect: today we launch the synthesis essay arc — this is the term's big piece
Direct instruction
15 minToday we launch your synthesis essay — the term's big piece. You'll draft over weeks 5-16; you'll publish in week 17; you'll present at the Symposium in week 18. Today we do two things: (1) apply the BIG6 SYNTHESIS STAGE (stage 5 of the research process you learned in G7-fall) to your 3 sources, and (2) learn 5 more Tier-2 Set 17 words. The Big6 stages: task definition, info-seeking strategies, location and access, use of information, SYNTHESIS, evaluation. You've done stages 1-4 (you have a topic and sources). Now you SYNTHESIZE — combine the 3 sources into a single argument. The synthesis-conversation map (MG-2) is your tool: where do sources AGREE? where do they EXTEND each other? where do they QUALIFY each other? where do they CONTRADICT each other? The 5 new words today: ARTICULATE (express clearly in words); POSIT (put forward as a basis for argument); CONTEND (argue assertively for a position); CONCEDE (acknowledge a point the opponent makes); REFUTE (disprove a claim with evidence and reasoning). Notice these are VERBS — they describe what writers DO. Use them in your prose: 'Adichie posits that...' is stronger than 'Adichie thinks that...'
-
Tier-2 verbs are stronger than generic verbs. Use them.model 'Adichie articulates the harm of single stories by integrating personal anecdote with cultural observation.' Notice: articulates is more precise than says — it implies clarity and structure.prompt Apply ARTICULATE in a sentence about Adichie's argument.
-
Concede + contend is a sophisticated They-Say/I-Say move.model 'While Coates concedes that progress has been made, he contends that the structural inequities remain.' Notice: CONCEDE marks the acknowledgment; CONTEND marks the persistence of argument.prompt Apply CONCEDE in a synthesis sentence.
- Pair-share: tell your partner where 2 of your 3 sources AGREE, EXTEND, QUALIFY, or CONTRADICT each other.
- Cold Call: use POSIT in a sentence.
M-8-F-WR-05-A
Chart
MG-2 anchor with 3 named sources and arrows labeled. Print-ready 18x24.
MG-2
Chart
Synthesis-conversation map anchor: 3-source web template. Three circles labeled SOURCE A, SOURCE B, SOURCE C; arrows between them labeled AGREES (green), EXTENDS (blue), QUALIFIES (yellow), CONTRADICTS (red). A central diamond labeled MY ARGUMENT — the writer's synthesis claim sits at the center, drawing on all three sources. Rule at bottom: 'Synthesis means the sources CONVERSE — through your argument. If your essay reads source-A, source-B, source-C in sequence with no cross-talk, you have a literature review, not a synthesis.' Worked example: Adichie + Coates + Wallace-Wells on the danger of single narratives. Print-ready 18x24.
Guided practice
25 min-
Fill out the synthesis-conversation map (MG-2) for your 3 sources. Identify at least 2 cross-source relationships (agrees / extends / qualifies / contradicts).scaffold MG-2 anchor at desk; sample completed map from teacher exemplar
-
Draft your synthesis essay's working thesis — one sentence that captures the synthesis argument emerging from your map. Use at least one Tier-2 verb (articulate, posit, contend, concede, refute, synthesize, integrate, illuminate).scaffold Thesis sentence-frame: 'While [source A] [verb] X, [source B] [verb] Y, suggesting that ___.'
M-8-F-WR-05-B
Chart
MG-12 anchor: 6 Big6 stages with stage 5 SYNTHESIS highlighted. Shows synthesis as the move where sources combine into one argument. Print-ready 11x17.
Formative assessment
3 min- Submit your synthesis-conversation map.
- Submit your working thesis.
Closure
2 min- Restate: synthesis is Big6 stage 5 — sources combined into a single argument through the writer's thesis
- Preview lesson 6: gerunds (-ing as noun)
Homework
15 min- Refine your synthesis-conversation map. Revise your working thesis if needed. Add 2 Tier-2 Set 17 words to your vocabulary entries (chosen from today's 5).
Exercises in this lesson
Differentiation
- MG-2 synthesis-conversation map at desk
- Thesis sentence-frame card
- Pre-drafted map example from teacher exemplar
- Add 4th source to your set if synthesis is rich enough
- Draft 2 alternative working theses and choose the strongest
- Bilingual Tier-2 verb card
- Oral thesis drafting with peer before written
- Reduced source set (2 sources instead of 3)
- Pre-filled synthesis-map template skeleton
Teacher notes
Synthesis essay launch is the term's pivot point. From here, lessons 6-15 develop the grammatical/vocabulary tools while students continue drafting. Some students will discover their topic doesn't have enough source-conflict to support synthesis — coach toward topic refinement now, not later. Save the synthesis-conversation maps — they reveal where students are struggling to find cross-source friction. ELL students sometimes have rich oral-tradition sources (family stories, community elders) — explicitly invite these as legitimate sources alongside the scholarly/journalistic.