eng.g2.f.lesson_04.who_what_when_where_why_expansion
Sentence Expansion — Who/What/When/Where/Why/How
- Students expand a bare-bones sentence by answering one or more of the WH+H questions.
- Students identify which WH-question each expansion answers.
Lesson plan
Warm-up
5 minTeacher reads a bare-bones sentence ('The dog barked.'). Class generates one expansion question at a time aloud.
- Show that each question adds INFORMATION
- Resist demand for one perfect expansion — variety is the point
Direct instruction
12 minHochman gave writers a tool — to grow a thin sentence into a thick one, ASK QUESTIONS of it. WHO did it? WHAT happened? WHEN did it happen? WHERE? WHY? HOW? Each question answered becomes a phrase you add. Watch: 'The dog barked.' → WHO? My neighbor's dog. WHEN? At midnight. WHY? Because a raccoon was on the porch. New sentence: 'My neighbor's dog barked at midnight because a raccoon was on the porch.'
-
Notice — WHEN (after school), WHAT KIND (warm chocolate-chip), WHERE (in my kitchen), WHY (because I was starving).model After school, I ate three warm chocolate-chip cookies in my kitchen because I was starving.prompt Expand: I ate cookies.
- Which WH-question did I just answer when I added 'in my kitchen'?
- Could the same sentence be expanded with different answers and still be true?
M-2-F-WR-04-A
Chart
Six-card chart laid out in a row: WHO (silhouette icon, blue), WHAT (box icon, orange), WHEN (clock icon, red), WHERE (pin-on-map icon, green), WHY (arrow-back icon, purple), HOW (gear icon, brown). Each card includes the question word in 60pt font and a sample answer phrase below in 24pt. Print-ready, dyslexic-friendly font.
Guided practice
13 min-
Hochman expansion drill — teacher provides 5 bare sentences ('Maya ran.', 'The cat slept.', 'Dad cooked.', 'We laughed.', 'Mom drove.'). Children write expanded versions answering at least 3 WH-questions.scaffold WH-card set on desk
-
Color-code: in your strongest expansion, underline WHO in blue, WHEN in red, WHERE in green, WHY in purple.
M-2-F-WR-04-B
Diagram
Two-panel diagram. LEFT: thin bare sentence 'The dog barked.' shown as a stick figure of a dog. RIGHT: thick expanded sentence 'My neighbor's dog barked at midnight because a raccoon was on the porch.' shown as fuller scene illustration with a dog mid-bark, a moon, and a raccoon on a porch. Color-coded annotations point from each WH-card to the new phrase. Print-ready 11x17.
Formative assessment
3 min- Take 'My family laughed.' and expand it by answering THREE WH-questions in one sentence.
Closure
2 min- Read your best expanded sentence to your partner — partner names which WH-questions were answered.
- Tomorrow: adjectives and adverbs — words that color a sentence.
Homework
10 min- Pick a bare sentence about your day ('I went to ___') and expand it by answering three WH-questions. Write in notebook.
Exercises in this lesson
Differentiation
- WH-card prompts on desk (color-coded)
- Sentence frame 'WHO ___ + DID WHAT ___ + WHERE ___ + WHEN ___ + WHY ___'
- Expand the same bare sentence three different ways with different WH-answers.
- Combine two expanded sentences with a Grade-1 conjunction.
- Bilingual WH-card prompts
- Oral expansion before writing
- Two-question expansion sufficient
- Hand-over-hand drawing of the WH-icons
Teacher notes
Hochman's expansion drill is the single highest-leverage move in K-5 writing. Run it for 10 minutes every week for the rest of the term — even five fresh sentences a week compounds. Watch for over-expansion (every sentence becomes a 25-word monster); the goal is OPTION, not maximalism.