hist.g6.f.ex_39
Source Analysis
MG-7
Interactive
Physical / non-image
Ancient-World 6-Question Source Card — 8.5x11 laminated tool with 6 questions: (1) WHO made this source and WHEN? (sourcing); (2) WHAT was happening in this civilization at the time? (contextualization); (3) DOES this source agree or disagree with other sources from the same civilization or other civilizations? (corroboration); (4) WHAT does this source actually SAY (close reading); (5) WHO are the LIVING DESCENDANTS of this civilization today, and what do they say about this source? (NMAI-inspired 5th move); (6) WHO TRANSLATED this source from its ancient language? WHOSE INTERPRETATION are we reading? WHAT IS LIKELY MISSING from the source-record entirely (silences)? (World History Association-inspired 6th move). Scaffolded short-form for Lessons 3-7; full form for Lessons 11-21. Style: educator-tool, durable laminated card.
Apply MG-7 Source Card to Pliny the Younger Letters 6.16 + 6.20 (describing Vesuvius eruption 79 CE + uncle Pliny the Elder's death attempting rescue, written 25 years after to Tacitus). Particular attention to LIVING DESCENDANTS (modern Italians) and CORROBORATION (archaeological evidence at Pompeii + Herculaneum corroborates).
- WHO/WHEN: Pliny the Younger writing to Tacitus c. 105 CE about 79 CE eruption.
- Corroboration: Pompeii + Herculaneum archaeology.
- Treating Pliny's letters as 'just literary,'
- Forgetting that Pliny wrote 25 years AFTER the event