Apply Wineburg 4-question routine plus NMAI 'whose voice is silent' fifth move to a treaty or land-cession document
Exercise
Difficulty 5
~8 min
hist.g4.f.ex_13
Full Wineburg Doc5
Prompt
Apply the FULL Wineburg 4-question routine plus NMAI fifth move to Doc-5 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo Article IX excerpt (CA example - LOCALIZE). Write all 5 responses.
How it's presented
mode
archive card full
prompt audio ID
audio.g4f.ex 13.stem
Answer criteria
type
archive card response
rubric
All 5 question responses present AND silent-voice correctly identified as Indigenous-nation voices whose homelands the treaty redistributes AND cross-corroboration with Doc-1 named
Hints
- Question 5: whose voice is silent in a treaty between two non-Indigenous governments deciding fate of Indigenous-nation homelands?
- Cross-corroborate with Doc-1 own-voice statement.
Misconceptions to watch
- Treating the treaty as neutral legal document
- Skipping the fifth NMAI move
- Reading only document text without contextualization
Used in lessons