Plan, research, draft, revise, peer-edit, and publish a 5-6 paragraph argument with at least 2 sources and 1 counterclaim (CCSS W.6.1.a-e)
Exercise Difficulty 5 ~4 min eng.g6.f.ex_42

Practice Qa Concede Pivot Refute

Prompt

Practice 2 Q&A responses using the concede-pivot-refute frame. Partner asks from Q&A deck. Respond in ~30 seconds each.

M-6-F-WR-EX-42-A Manipulative Physical / non-image

Q&A question deck per M-6-F-WR-20-C. 10 cards with sample questions. Reverse has concede-pivot-refute frame for response.

Answer criteria
type rubric
rubric
Both responses use concede-pivot-refute + evidence-based + within time = 4; 1 of 2 = 3; both partial = 2; dismissals = 1
Hints
  1. Even live, the move is concede-pivot-refute.
  2. Q&A is high-stakes for steel-manning.
Misconceptions to watch
  • Dismisses the question.
  • Rambles past 30 seconds.
Used in lessons