Apply the 10-criterion G5 essay-mode peer-editing rubric to a partner's essay draft
Exercise Difficulty 4 ~15 min eng.g5.f.ex_37

Peer Edit 10 Criterion

MG-13 Chart Physical / non-image

10-criterion G5 essay-mode peer-editing rubric check-off sheet (print-ready 8.5x11, one per peer-edit cycle): 1. INTRODUCTION HAS HOOK + TOPIC-ORIENTING CONTEXT + THESIS-WITH-THREE-REASONS. 2. 3 BODY PARAGRAPHS WITH TEEL (topic + evidence + explanation + link). 3. LINK SENTENCE CONNECTS EACH BODY BACK TO THE THESIS. 4. AUDIENCE-AWARE WORD CHOICE AND STRUCTURE (audience-analysis card matches the prose). 5. AT LEAST 2 IN-TEXT CITATIONS (signal-phrase OR parenthetical). 6. WORKS-CITED LIST WITH AT LEAST 2 ENTRIES. 7. CONSISTENT VERB TENSE (no inappropriate shifts). 8. AT LEAST 1 CORRELATIVE-CONJUNCTION PAIR USED. 9. VARIED SENTENCE STRUCTURE (at least 1 expanded, 1 combined, 1 reduced sentence visible). 10. CONCLUSION SYNTHESIZES (pulls reasons together, not just summary). Each criterion has YES/PARTLY/NO checkbox, notes line, and a quote-or-example space.

Prompt

Apply MG-13 10-criterion rubric to your partner's draft. Mark YES/PARTLY/NO with specific notes. Suggest ≥1 named revision move for each PARTLY/NO.

M-5-F-EX-37 Illustration Physical / non-image

Reference image of a completed 10-criterion rubric sheet with marks, notes, and move suggestions. Print-ready 8.5x11.

How it's presented
mode rubric check off
Answer criteria
type rubric
criteria
  1. All 10 criteria marked
  2. Each has specific note (quote/example)
  3. Each PARTLY/NO has move suggestion
  4. Did NOT re-write partner draft
Hints
  1. Be honest. Marking YES on everything defeats the rubric.
  2. Quote partner's writing in notes.
Misconceptions to watch
  • Re-writes partner's draft.
  • Marks YES on everything.
Used in lessons